Avethan Schedule Your Free Consultation

Navigating Online Tracking Technologies: A Comprehensive Guide for HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates

Navigating Online Tracking Technologies: A Comprehensive Guide for HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates

The digital age has brought a host of technological advancements, dramatically reshaping the healthcare industry. Technology has become integral to healthcare delivery and management, from telehealth services to mobile health applications. However, with these advancements come increased privacy and security challenges. 

Understanding Online Tracking Technologies

HIPAA, enacted in 1996, was designed to protect the privacy and security of individuals' health information while allowing for the flow of health information needed to provide high-quality healthcare. At the core of HIPAA is the Privacy Rule and the Security Rule. The Privacy Rule establishes national standards for protecting PHI by covered entities and business associates. On the other hand, the Security Rule sets standards for protecting PHI that is held or transferred electronically, also known as electronic protected health information (ePHI).

What are Online Tracking Technologies?

At their core, online tracking technologies are tools designed to gather and analyze data about how users interact with digital platforms, including websites and mobile applications. They track user behavior, such as the pages visited, the time spent on each page, the links clicked, the searches made, and much more. This information is invaluable for businesses to understand their audience, improve their services, and tailor their offerings to meet user preferences.

For instance, these technologies can help providers understand patient behavior, identify trends, improve patient care, and enhance the user experience. However, if misused, these tools can potentially enable activities such as promoting misinformation, facilitating identity theft, enabling stalking, and causing harassment.

Types of Online Tracking Technologies

Online tracking technologies come in various forms, each with unique capabilities, uses, and implications. Here are some of the most commonly used types:

Cookies: These are small text files that websites store on a user's device to remember information about the user or their interaction with the site. They can be used to remember login details, track user activity across sessions, personalize content, and more. Cookies can be further classified into "first-party" cookies, set by the website you're visiting, and "third-party" cookies, set by a different domain, often for advertising or analytics purposes.

Web Beacons or Tracking Pixels: Designed to be tiny, transparent images embedded in websites or emails, when a user opens a webpage or email containing a beacon, it returns information about the user's interaction with the server. This info can include the user's IP address, the time the beacon was viewed, and the type of browser used. These tools are often used to track user behavior and measure the effectiveness of advertising campaigns or email marketing efforts.

Session Replay Scripts: Scripts record how users interact with a website, capturing actions like mouse movements, clicks, scrolls, and keystrokes. This can provide a wealth of user experience data, helping businesses identify usability issues, improve site design, and enhance user engagement. However, if not properly managed, these scripts can also capture sensitive information, raising privacy concerns.

Fingerprinting Scripts: Used to collect data about a user's device, such as the operating system, browser version, installed fonts, and screen resolution, this information can create a unique "fingerprint" of the device. This can be used to track users across different websites, even if they clear their cookies or use private browsing modes.

How Tracking Technologies Work in Healthcare

In healthcare, tracking technologies can be developed internally or implemented using third-party solutions. They can be used in various ways, such as improving the functionality of patient portals, understanding patient behavior, enhancing telehealth services, or conducting health research.

However, it's crucial to note that third-party tracking technologies can present additional risks. They often send information directly to the developers and can continue to track users even after they navigate away from the original website. For instance, mobile apps often embed tracking codes to collect user-provided data and capture device-related information, such as a unique device ID or advertising ID.

HIPAA Rules and Tracking Technologies: An In-depth Look

The nature of the webpage on which a tracking technology is placed – whether user-authenticated or unauthenticated – plays a crucial role in how the HIPAA rules apply.

Tracking on User-authenticated Webpages

User-authenticated web pages require users to log in to access the content. These could include patient portals, telehealth platforms, or other services that need user authentication. Tracking technologies on such webpages usually have access to PHI, such as an individual’s IP address, medical record number, home or email address, dates of appointments, or other identifying information.

HIPAA-regulated entities must configure these web pages to ensure that the tracking technologies only use and disclose PHI in compliance with the HIPAA Privacy Rule. They must also ensure that the ePHI collected through the website is secured in accordance with the HIPAA Security Rule.

Given the sensitive nature of the data collected on user-authenticated web pages, healthcare organizations must implement stringent measures to safeguard this information. This can include data encryption, secure data transmission protocols, and rigorous access control mechanisms. Regular monitoring and auditing of these processes is essential to identify and rectify potential security gaps.

Tracking on Unauthenticated Webpages

Unauthenticated web pages do not require users to log in before accessing the webpage. Examples include webpages with general information about a healthcare entity, such as its location, services, policies, and procedures. 

However, sometimes tracking technologies on unauthenticated web pages may have access to PHI. For example, a user may inadvertently disclose PHI when submitting a form or inquiring on an unauthenticated webpage. In such cases, the HIPAA rules apply to the entities’ use of tracking technologies and their disclosures to tracking technology vendors. Examples of identifiers include:

  • Full names

  • All geographic identifiers smaller than a state

  • All elements of dates (except year) 

  • Telephone numbers

  • Fax numbers

  • Email addresses

  • Social Security numbers

  • Numbers assigned to individual medical records

  • Health insurance beneficiary numbers

  • Bank account numbers

  • Certificate or license numbers

  • Vehicle identifiers and serial numbers, including license plate numbers

  • Identifiers and serial numbers of devices

  • Web Universal Resource Locators (URLs)

  • Internet Protocol (IP) addresses

  • Biometric identifiers, such as finger and voice prints

  • Full-face photos and other comparable images

  • Any other unique identifier, characteristic, or code (this does not refer to the unique code assigned by an investigator to code the data)

Implementing Appropriate Safeguards

Apart from entering into BAAs, healthcare organizations should implement appropriate administrative, physical, and technical safeguards to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and security of electronically protected health information, as required by the HIPAA Security Rule.

Administrative Safeguards involve conducting a risk analysis to identify potential vulnerabilities in the handling of PHI and implementing security measures to reduce these risks. It also involves designating a security official responsible for developing and implementing security policies and procedures.

Physical Safeguards focus on limiting physical access to facilities and systems where PHI is stored, while ensuring authorized access is allowed. This could involve implementing policies regarding workstation and device security, including the transfer, removal, disposal, and re-use of electronic media.

Technical Safeguards involve implementing technology and policies to control access to PHI and protect it from unauthorized access or transmission. This includes implementing encryption protocols, unique user identification systems, automatic logoff procedures, and audit control mechanisms.

Ensuring Patient Rights

The HIPAA Privacy Rule also provides individuals with rights over their PHI, including rights to examine and obtain a copy of their health records and to request corrections. Healthcare organizations should ensure that their use of tracking technologies does not infringe upon these rights. For instance, if a patient requests access to their PHI, this should include any data collected through tracking technologies.

HIPAA-Compliant Design of Tracking Technologies

Tracking technologies themselves should also be designed with HIPAA compliance in mind. This includes ensuring that data collected is minimized to only what is necessary for the intended purpose, that data is encrypted in transit and at rest, and that the technology has the necessary controls to ensure that only authorized individuals can access the data.

For example, a wearable device collecting patient health data should have robust authentication mechanisms to ensure that only the patient and authorized healthcare providers can access the data. Similarly, any web-based tracking technologies should use secure protocols (like HTTPS) to encrypt data in transit, and have robust access controls to prevent unauthorized access.

Ensuring Ongoing Compliance

Ensuring HIPAA compliance when using tracking technologies isn't a one-time event, but an ongoing process. As technology evolves, so too do the threats to PHI. Healthcare organizations must regularly review and update their policies and procedures, train their staff, and conduct audits to ensure ongoing compliance.

This includes staying up-to-date with updates to the HIPAA regulations. For instance, the Office for Civil Rights (OCR), the body responsible for enforcing HIPAA, regularly issues guidance on how HIPAA applies to new technologies and situations. Healthcare organizations should regularly review this guidance and adjust their policies and procedures as necessary.

Business Associate Agreements

A Business Associate Agreement (BAA) is an essential component of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) compliance. This agreement is a legally binding document between a healthcare provider (or any entity covered under HIPAA) and a business associate. A business associate is any organization or person working with or providing services to a covered entity who handles or discloses Protected Health Information (PHI) or Electronic Protected Health Information (ePHI).

The key elements of a BAA include:

  • Permitted Uses and Disclosures: The BAA specifies how the business associate can use and disclose PHI. It outlines the specific purposes for which PHI can be used, which must be in line with HIPAA regulations. The minimal necessary standard should be applied, meaning that only the minimum necessary information needed to perform a task should be used or disclosed.

  • Safeguards: The BAA must detail the safeguards the business associate will implement to protect PHI. These safeguards can be administrative, technical, or physical and are meant to prevent unauthorized access to PHI.

  • Data Breach Procedures: The BAA should include procedures to follow in the case of a data breach. This includes the obligation of the business associate to report any breaches of unsecured PHI to the covered entity. The report should include any security incidents, the actions taken to mitigate the harm, and what steps will be taken to prevent future breaches.

  • Termination: The BAA should include terms for its termination. If the covered entity finds out that the business associate has violated a key term in the BAA, the covered entity is obligated to first try to correct the violation. If this is not possible, the contract should be terminated.

  • Subcontractors: If a business associate discloses protected health information to a subcontractor or allows a subcontractor to create or receive PHI on their behalf, the business associate must ensure that the subcontractor agrees to the same restrictions and conditions.

The BAA is a critical tool in ensuring that PHI is adequately protected and that all parties understand their responsibilities under HIPAA. Failure to have a proper BAA in place can result in significant fines and penalties for HIPAA violations.

Risk Assessment and Management

Undertaking regular risk assessments is another essential step in ensuring HIPAA compliance when using tracking technologies. These assessments should identify potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI. Once risks are identified, organizations should implement security measures to reduce them reasonably and appropriately.

Risk management also includes implementing incident response plans to address potential data breaches. These plans should outline steps to identify and contain the breach, notify affected individuals and the Department of Health and Human Services, and mitigate the effects of the violation.

Training and Awareness

Employee training plays a significant role in HIPAA compliance. All organization members who may contact PHI should receive training on HIPAA regulations and the organization's policies and procedures for protecting PHI. This training should be updated periodically to address changes in the regulatory landscape or the organization's practices.

Furthermore, entities should foster a culture of privacy and security awareness. This can be achieved through regular communications, reminders, and activities highlighting the importance of protecting PHI and complying with HIPAA rules.

Proper Implementation

Unauthorized disclosures can lead to legal penalties and erode this trust, which is detrimental to the provider-patient relationship. Therefore, while leveraging the power of technology, healthcare entities must also prioritize protecting their patients' privacy and security.

Navigating these complexities can be challenging. If you need assistance understanding and implementing digital privacy and security measures in your healthcare practice, don't hesitate to contact Avethan. We're committed to helping healthcare entities uphold the highest data protection standards while harnessing the benefits of digital innovation.